Tag: murder

  • Forget-Me-Naught Pt. 3

    By: M. R. Vega


    † These are the recordings of Joel D. Braunagh. Patient #19-374222. Case #9119 Det. Milton # 617

    Date/Time – May 14th, 2009, 8:00 p.m.

    Pt. #19-374222 J.D.Braunagh


    -+- Evening Joel. Once again, for general purposes, I am Detective Rachel Milton. This is a recording of Joel’s discussions with me, over a divulging of details about the box, the altercation between Michael Braunagh; the brother.

    -+- Night three Joel. Are you ready? Can we do this tonight? At least the box, please?

    — I already told you I’d tell you, I’ll share everything. It’s going back and tracing the steps that knocks the f*** out of me. Leaving me completely drained and more than frustrated, it’s more than agonizing to separate that frustration with the law and the obvious situation that has me here. But of course, that’s not sensical to any of you, is it? But I already confessed to everything. I did it sorrowfully but willfully, taking the accountability for the loss of all three because it’s my hands that created the situation. It’s bad enough that I don’t get to put them in the ground!

    -+- Joel as a matter of fact, its a legal right for you, they’ll let you go to each funeral. But, we need to get this documented; we need to know, like I keep telling you. Deal?

    — Well that is a horse of a different f****** color ain’t it? Not that it was our plan to begin with, burying that is. I think we both wanted to become ash, like what we came from. At least, *sigh* it wasn’t set, not yet, we hadn’t even bought plots yet. Sorry, (sucks on teeth), I digress sorry, god I f****** miss her.

    ‡ Joel grabs at the nape of his neck and rocks back and forth for a moment grimacing at the tile beneath his obnoxious orange gel slides.

    -+- I’m sorry Joel. Truly but we do need to know what happened. What was it that happened after Luca died? (I pause for a moment, waiting to see that register, he doesn’t stir, doesn’t blink, or really pay mind), What happened, aside from the magazine collecting Joel, you’re a toy maker, the most you’ve done is what? Wind-em-up toys or pullbacks is that what they call these?

    ‡ I pull out a small plastic duck with wheels from out of my blazer pocket.  I pull it back pressing against the surface of the floor table desk and let go. I do this, position it to tap against his prison shoe, and when it hits it, he looks down, looks at me, sighs heavily nodding his head.

    — Yes and no, the person who made the ducks actually, her name is Jessica Stewart, I wasn’t ever really a big fan of her craft but we worked in the same tier level.

    — Anyway, no, I did more than just the simple machine type of toy, we had a production line that was similar to magnetic tiles but made sounds, and we were in the process of an interlocking block system that was definitely going to bring us to court with Lego, but I guess it doesn’t matter. (He grimaces again, shakes his head with a face that looks of disgust.) But no I…I did action figures, I did the molding, I did some robotics but on a minute and basic level and  no I…I…just happened to stop, I didn’t do anything for a while. You, *sigh*, I don’t know how to put it because I didn’t just lose my boy Rachel, I lost the fire of my life. It wasn’t until after Luca’s death, that had me realize truths to what Celeste and I were. We became a stagnant mass of gelatin together and alone. She loathed me and I the same with her but then cowered back with a loving embrace because we were alone. What with him passing away there was such a resounding loss in the both of us…that my wife and I, we couldn’t, she couldn’t escape. It was more like being shot into space knowing no one would catch us…we were just alone, together, of course.

    — But, it’s not the same…it’s not the same. It was never going to be the same and this wasn’t just killing Celeste, it was wreaking havoc on the mental health of our baby girl who now, had nothing.

    ‡ Joel grabs the small duck, pulls back a distance further than expected and lets go of the toy, leaving the duck sailing toward my feet and under my chair. He gives a meek smile. And continued…

    — We were both well aware of Zappy; the little five years old and her curious mind. She had a bit of an inclination of what actually happened though and just knowing that her brother was gone had deeply resonated within her and Celeste and I didn’t come to help build her up. We were too busy inside ourselves. But we did tell her that Luca went for the long sleep, she understood but kept saying he’d come back. That was until the ‘sealing‘ happened.

    -+- The sealing? Can you elaborate…you know I’ll have more questions to that Joel, what is that, the sealing?

    — Relax, I’m getting to it.

    — Promise

    ‡ Joel smiles, he’s starting to get moderately comfortable.

    — But as parents, we tried to…we carried it as best as we could but we stayed silent, we had become those that loved one another indefinitely, but somehow allowed the grief to eviscerate the idea of anything else but loss and the idea of Luca not being here. I lost myself, I was put on suspension with my job and started letting my team down, my activity at work severely lessened where I started running behind with everything. I started losing weight, even went so far to malnourish her due being blind. That’s how negligent and calous we were. But then thankfully Michael came.

    -+- Okay, so your brother was involved, your brother was a happy extension of the family and obviously had helped, with what I’m assuming, all of it?

    — Yeah exactly, he took me down into the basement and saw the stacks of magazines, copper wires, more metal sheets, bolts, crystal shards, more wire, and metal. Oh, and piled up earth magnets that were likely causing everything above us to go on the fritz and just held me.

    Joel let out a heavy sigh and visible tears were falling from his chin. They’d occasionally pool and hang for a moment in his meek goatee and fall soaking the gels wrapped around his feet

    — I let everything out, I melted in his arms and lost the ability to stand, and I think Michael knew, he knew how far gone Celeste and I had gone with just the entirety of our loss. So him showing up when he did, well it was bound to happen, I’m grateful it did, but at the same time, sorry that it did and I don’t get to tell him that.

    -+- How long did he stay with you?

    — A couple months until he thought he was seeing that we were getting back on our feet, he did help me keep my job, but he had also had some issue with what I was trying to make in the basement.

    -+- The box, okay so Michael had nothing to do with the box?

    — No, not a f****** chance, no, he thought what I was trying to do was idiotic, and thought I was being more than a fool, I don’t know, obviously he wasn’t wrong, look at where we’re at. What I’m f****** wearing, these are god damn jellies on my feet. This is ridiculous, I get it, and I know why, I’m just venting for a moment.

    -+- That’s okay, I get it. Honest. -+- Not wanting to be somewhere when it’s needed but if the opportunity arose, you’d be gone…trust me, Joel I get it.

    — Yeah, okay Rachel, okay. Anyhow, back to Michael, he was seeing that we were okay but there was something off…something dauntingly trepidatious, especially for Celeste. Sadly neither of us saw…‡ Joel inhales sharply through clenched teeth…I don’t know how we missed it.  She must be a hell of a thespian.

    — Anyhow Michael was seeing that she couldn’t handle the second floor hallway on her way to the Master bedroom, it went right by Luca’s open door and it wrecked her every f****** day, every moment that called for going anywhere near, which was always. She had become frail, nearly a different woman, her eyes sunken in, her cheeks shallow and pale, eyes near glossed and she looked more than haggard. Celeste was becoming a broke form of what she once was and all we thought was something so simple. How do we close the room off?

    — Brick and mortar was the answer and we started the next day, for a brief moment it looked like a scene from The Cask of Amontillado, brick and mortar, brick and mortar. We had the door and a good three feet in sealed up and off and drywalled over that leaving us an extended hallway as though it had always been there.

    -+- And did this help?

    — Mmm, for a bit Detective, maybe a month, maybe two, enough that I finished the box.

    To be continued…

  • Forget-Me-Naught Pt. 2


    † These are the recordings of Joel D. Braunagh. Patient #19-374222. Case #9119 Det. Milton # 617

    Discussions encase “the box”, admittance of guilt to victims: Brother -Michael Braunagh, Wife – Celeste Braunagh, Daughter – Zappy Braunagh

    Date/TimeMay 13th, 2009, 8:00 p.m.

    Pt. #19-374222 J.D.Braunagh


    † Pt. #19-374222 J.D. Braunagh was given 05.12.2009 for Temporary Leave upon approval from D.A. Kingsley with police detail to coroner facility and grave site of both Celeste Braunagh and Zaporah Braunagh for funeral services.

    Discussion 2

    -+-Good Evening Mr. Braunagh, again, as a formality, this conversation and all details will be recorded and held to the courts for delibierstions on sentencing. I, again, am Detective Rachel Milton and will be having today’s inquiries and details scribed and recorded. Now, may I get you a pack of smokes, a pop, maybe some coffee? Anything Mr. Braunagh? 

    ‡Braunagh gives a heavy sigh, scoffs, rolls his head over his shoulders and nape of neck, shakes his head.

    -+-I heard you had the privilege of joining your family yesterday and sharing some goodbyes. How are you holding up Braunagh?

    Silence, shoes shuffling, a heavy sigh. Braunagh whispers incoherently.

    -+-Would you speak up Mr. Braunagh.

    ‡ Braunagh lifts up two fingers, assuming a notion to quiet the talking.

    — Detective Milton, if I have to ask you again to call me Joel, I’ll never give you a thing, doesn’t matter what the judge, D.A, or your captain ‘Surly‘ says. Do you have any idea the amount of isolation my entirety has dealt with?

    -+-I didn’t mean to offend, my apologies Joel. I do have to ask though how was their isolation if your family was in the house with you during…well (hmmm), elaborate if you can Joel.

    — No, I’ll get to that, to the box, the evidence, all the content agreed with the department and courts. I had assumed you wanted me to answer the other question about saying goodbye.

    ‡ Braunagh quits, shuffles his feet and stands up and starts to pace.

    — Sorry, is this allowed? Me walking around?

    -+-Yes, Joel, stay behind the table, the cameras are on too, as long as you stay composed, rational, and don’t give an excuse to who’s watching from there.

    ‡ I issued a finger toward the camera above me, Braunagh nods with acceptance and understanding. Smiles and continues.

    — Saying goodbye was, it was a weighted ordeal detective. You ever have to say goodbye to a loved one?

    — The thing is Detective, yesterday was more for me confirming what I had done. I had seen the condition they were both in at the house not but four days ago. But, they had already unraveled, I’d already known, I knew I was losing them every minute I couldn’t get that f****** box controlled, or contained.

    -+-Okay, thank you for your honesty, so you had already said goodbye? But just the other day, the 11th, you run this whole line how you didn’t get to say goodbye. How can you say one thing and then confirm with another statement today setting a stage for falsehoods? What was that for Joel? We need a 100% type of relaying the information, everything’s recorded Joel, you asking one thing the other day readjusting a statement to fit into your needs later on not remembering the things you had said prior are just going to set you up for failure with me. You need to be 100% with every word you share, every single bit is going to be weighed measured and will be the determining factor of how long you’re behind those bars. You do know that Mr. Braunagh, right?

    ‡ Braunagh scowls and shows a meek smile of disgust.

    -+-Sorry, Joel, you know right? You have to be able to confidently relay all details, to tell me the whole truth, okay?

    — Yes, yes, a thousand f****** times Rachel, yes! I’ve already agreed to the entirety of the deal, I will give you all the details.

    -+-Okay then, so where would you like to start Joel. The other day you had shared the loss of your son. I couldn’t even be able to find a way to understand that kind of a loss, especially such a harrowing and terrible way in losing him, I am so, again, very, very sorry about that Joel. What was it that happened after?

    — I’ll tell you this Rachel, if it wasn’t for our little one, Zappy, I would have ran back up that hill and jumped off to end it all. But I know I couldn’t have left Celeste like that. Can I assume you’ve already looked at the files for that incident with my son?

    -+-Yes, Joel. And before you ask, yes, all evidence points to signs of a natural incident to the cause of your son’s death. I truly am sorry for your loss. Most of us at the department don’t think you’re a killer Joel, I know I don’t. Being a mother and having my baby, there isn’t anything in my gut that tells me you’re a bad person, that’s why I’m the one here, I begged my captain to give me this detail, I had a gut feeling that there was something we were missing, so please continue Joel.

    — Celeste was at home was happy when he died. It was a little dad and son adventure up in Beulah, we were collecting butterflies for his collection. Those f****** butterflies.

    -+-How do you mean?

    — After I called 911, after the police and EMT crew, after his body was put on the gurney, I was put in the back of a police squad car and driven back home. I knocked on my f****** door not with my son’s hand in mine but with a box of fluttering butterflies and a cop behind me some really hanging his head down. I couldn’t f****** look at her. My heart could barely stand being there. I had still had the blood on me his blood, my hands were caked with it, and the look on her face was in absolute horror. She wailed, screamed to the f****** skies, and made sure that I felt every bit of pain that she was dealing with. It didn’t matter that the cops were there, it didn’t matter that the lights were still dancing on the house, it didn’t matter that my grief was right there with her, she started throwing her hands atop my head, my face, my chest and everything of me she could wallop on. I wrap my arms around her, begged for her forgiveness and we fell to the floor together in a heap while the cops tried to handle the chaos of my house.

    — I knew then, I knew that she had hated me, the moment that door opened and my son wasn’t in my hand standing there as well, I knew there was no way she could ever forgive my failure and saving her baby. Even still the pit that is my heart remains as empty as it was that day, I know it’s not fair, I knew it wasn’t fair to my daughter, I knew it wasn’t fair to my baby, my f****** wife, I failed all of them, the s*** has a dad who couldn’t keep his hands on his f****** son to make sure he didn’t fall had just lost any respect, any love, any regard to being a part of our family. I completely failed. F***, how long am I going to have to do this before it stops hurting?

    ‡ Braunagh pulls a Djarum, a small cigar, from behind his ear, strikes a match, pulls at the flame, and starts to inhale the clove scented smoke and continues.

    — Sorry Rachel…just need to breathe, just breathe Joel.

    — The police had us sign some forms, and gave us a day or two to settle after our son’s passing. Next we went to the coroner, that day that day too I wanted to die, there was such a guilt, there was such this tremendous and excruciating weight in all of the failure, all of the action not taken that led to us being there at the Coroner’s office, I did everything I could to keep my lips shut, my jaw tight and just stood behind her, behind Celeste in case she was going to faint, or in case any more chaos was to come from her or the both of us. It wasn’t easy then and even going over it now I can still see her face, see the tears flooding down, collecting at her chin, the snot that blended with all of it and all she wanted to do was kiss her baby. All she wanted what’s the fill that warmth again from him, and I can I can still see your hands with this tremor of a shake trying, just trying so so painfully to touch what is now about as cold as the metal he was laying on and she trembled, Rachel she f****** troubled so much. And I didn’t know what to do, I had no idea what in the flying hell was to be done to help rectify this? There wasn’t anything Rachel, sorry Detective.

    -+-Would you like a minute Joel? I can step out if needed.

    — No, no thank you, I just want to get this done.

    — That first day after she saw him and confirmed the horrors for herself, was one of the worst days of my life, and the week, weeks, the weeks and months that came after were no more better. She refused to close his door, refused to hide it, and eventually begged me to seal the door and replace it with the wall that essentially created a tomb of a past that neither of us would ever be able to return to.

    — I did exactly that, I listened to the wishes, called my brother Michael after ignoring his calls since our Luca died. But, then after the funeral, it was a lot harder to ignore him, a lot harder to shut the door and recoil in the grief, because Michael was a very involved family member, he was Uncle Michael and we let him share that grief. I did have him help me seal up the door, he too like myself wasn’t a fan of the idea, but I think both Michael and I knew it was the only way we could have Celeste find some type of composure, some type of peace even if it was more of a falsehood than actual peace.

    -+-What about your daughter, where was she during all of this?

    — This is something I’m not proud of, because of the good amount of years that were between Luca and Zappy, we had told Zappy that Luca had gone away for a very long trip. And yes she did go to the funeral with us, but I still feel that at the age she was at during that time the understanding of loss just for my wife was too much so sharing that grief and loss with zappy, I feel that both the voice as parents wanted to keep her protected, so we lied, lied about Luca leaving on a trip.

    -+-She didn’t ask about the door? She didn’t wonder where her brother’s room had gone to? I would assume that any kid could see very obvious things were happening, why? Why was that your take why did you shut her out in such, such a way?

    — I don’t f****** know, God damn it Rachel you seriously think I hadn’t gone through all of this, I haven’t questioned myself, my actions, every f****** day I don’t know. I wish I do and God how I wish there were so many f****** things I didn’t take to heart, didn’t take into action, and yes I failed my daughter just about as much as I failed Luca I’m well aware of that Rachel and I will forever question why I agreed with my wife and keeping her distant. And in all honesty I’m pretty sure she knew, Uncle Michael was a pretty conscientious one, constantly ragging on both Celeste and I to fix it with Zapp. Pretty sure he was the one who told her, and tried to tell her to keep it quiet that he was the one who told. But in all honesty I think he meant well, it did eventually make it easier down the road for Celeste, at least I’d like to think that it did.

    — After his funeral everything went quiet. The chaos…it’s not that it stopped, it’s not that the turmoil within drifted or evanesced into the drink, it just became a part of us. A couple months after the funeral her night terrors started, the blood curdling screams and howlings that permeated through our doors down the neighborhood streets and echoed, affecting the entire neighborhood. And I needed to find an outlet, whether it was an outlet for us, whether it was something that could be used for just her I need to find a conduit that could be associated with Luca. So I did research, research, reading, so much f****** reading so much tinkering and tailoring to pulling apart machines and breaking down old game sets and I just lost myself in trying to find my family again.

    — And this is where the isolation began, I shut the basement door and let Celeste take care of Zappy, having no idea of the detriment that I was creating, of the toxicity and spoiling of my little darling that I had just devised, thinking that her mom would find some resolve in making sure Zappy was better, but that idea of replacing one with the next was something else. I couldn’t fathom that my wife wouldn’t be able to see through the grief, I didn’t have the capacity in thinking Luca dying the way he did was so egregious that it made Celeste unable to look past that loss. And sadly I found Zappy cleaning up after her mom, cleaning up after herself, making her own little lunches for a homeschool system that was self created by my daughter, because Celeste was beside herself, creating a needing to grow up far too soon before a 5 year old needs to grow up and I stayed in the basement groveling in the loss trying to find a way to better this for Celeste, and for me.

    — I think I’m done today Rachel. I had thought going over this, especially in a more one-on-one basis would help, maybe be cathartic and finding a grasp of all of this, it just makes it that much more real and terrifying and that I single-handedly ended my family’s lives by accident. I didn’t f****** mean to, I need that to be known I didn’t mean to hurt any of them. Especially my baby girl and wife. I’m sorry Rachel, I’m going to ask that we stop and we’ll pick it up tomorrow. I’ll go over… f***, I’ll tell you about the box tomorrow okay?

    — You’re not going to like it, I know I don’t but I’ll give you every detail I can.

    -+-Okay Joel, we’ll respect your wishes, we are running out of time though so I am going to need you to start truly getting into detail about what I’m hoping will start giving us some bread crumbs to building up a sort of detailed schematics of where it began and how it ended.

    — You and me both Rachel, you and me both. Mind if I take another cigarette with me before I go back to my cell?

    ‡ I nod and issue toward the cigarette box where Braunagh take a one and awaits his guard to be ushered back to his cell.

    -+-Tgank you Joel, you have a good night, try to remember all you can from the box and making whatever that thing is. Want to try to get as much as I can recorded all right? I’ll see you tomorrow Joel.


    Scribed May 13th, 2009 -9:00 p.m. signed: R. T. Milton

    End of Discussion 1 Time – 9:00 p.m. 05/13/2009


    Songs listened to during Writing Forget -Me-Naught Pt. 2